My Favorite Pizza Place

Discover delicious, homemade pizza at My Favorite Pizza Place in Mohegan Lake, NY. Dine-in or takeout at 1745 E Main St. Call +1 914-528-8200 for great flavors today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to My Favorite Pizza Place

Taste the Difference.

My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place

Nestled in the heart of Mohegan Lake, My Favorite Pizza Place serves up authentic Italian flavors and warm hospitality. This bustling pizza restaurant at 1745 E Main St is a local gem, loved for its wide array of dishes that cater to all tastes. With 139 menu items, there's something for everyone—from classic pizzas and hearty pastas to fresh salads and delectable desserts.

The atmosphere buzzes with energy as families, friends, and neighbors gather to enjoy delicious meals and share laughter.

The cozy interior and friendly staff create a welcoming vibe that makes each visit a treat. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night snack, My Favorite Pizza Place promises an experience that delights taste buds and fosters connections.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1745 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, United States

Phone

+1 914-528-8200

About

The Culinary Story

My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place
My Favorite Pizza Place

My Favorite Pizza Place isn't just a restaurant; it's a community hub in Mohegan Lake. Opened to offer a slice of Italy to locals, it quickly became known for its commitment to quality ingredients and authentic recipes. The pizzeria prides itself on using fresh produce and local suppliers, ensuring that every dish embodies the flavors of the region.

Families and friends gather here, making memories over shared plates of pizza and pasta. The wide variety of menu items—139 in total—reflects the diverse tastes of the community. From gourmet pizzas like the Chicken Bacon Ranch to comforting classics like Chicken Parmigiana, the options are endless.

Every meal is crafted with care, featuring house-made sauces and generous portions that keep customers returning.

One highlight is the intimate outdoor seating area, allowing guests to enjoy their meals al fresco, especially during warm summer evenings. Local events and pizza nights frequently take place, bringing together residents for nights of food, fun, and laughter. It's a place where everyone knows your name, welcoming you back like family. My Favorite Pizza Place inspires community spirit while championing Italian culinary traditions, creating a delicious blend of flavors and friendships in the heart of Mohegan Lake.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

My Favorite Pizza Place boasts an extensive menu that highlights the best of Italian cuisine. With categories spanning appetizers, gourmet pizzas, entrees, and desserts, diners will find plenty of options to satisfy any craving. Appetizers like Eggplant Rollatini and Rice Balls tantalize the taste buds and make for excellent starters, while salads offer a refreshing choice for health-conscious diners.

For pasta lovers, the homemade lasagna and baked ziti options, along with various sauces, showcase the rich flavors of Italy. The children’s menu ensures that the littlest diners are well taken care of, featuring favorites such as Chicken Fingers and Gelato.

Dessert options stand out with classics like Tiramisu and dessert pizza, capping off your meal on a sweet note. Additionally, the warm, inviting ambiance complements the exquisite food, making it hard to resist coming back.

My Favorite Pizza Place

The exterior of My Favorite Pizza Place exudes charm, with inviting signage and warm lighting drawing patrons in from the street. The building’s cozy architecture gives a inviting feel, making it hard to resist stepping inside. The outdoor seating area features rustic tables and twinkling string lights, creating a perfect atmosphere for enjoying a meal under the stars.

Locals often gather here for impromptu discussions and laughs, turning the outdoor space into a lively social hub. The relaxing vibe perfectly complements the delectable food, making each visit feel like a community affair.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Went here for a slice of pizza on Monday November 6th, before heading to a funeral that was nearby. Went with my parents. They had quite a few pizzas and rolls available. I had a slice of BBQ Chicken pizza, my mom had white pizza with a spinach roll, and i forget what my dad had. i enjoyed my pizza, and liked the slice. Was also greeted right away, and everyone seemed very nice. Reasonable price too.

J
Jacqueline L.

Best pizza in Mohegan Lake! All the pizza is great but our favorites are the Grandma Margherita, Sicilian (light and airy) and the salad pizza is the best. If you've never had salad pizza and want to try it, be sure to get it here. Frank works non stop and we're glad he does!

L
Linda K.

The name says it all, it's my favorite pizza.

M
Michael M.

I'm from up north from NY and this is by far the best pizza I've ever had. Chicken and bacon ranch is a hit and the Mac attack should never be made anywhere else. Shout out to my employer for having a contract with a company in the same plaza as this spot. I WILL be returning.

J
Justin G.

Awesome food!!! Great Service. The scarpielo slice and dish is awesome and the buffalo slice is great. If you are in the area totally recommend it really is my favorite pizza place. Totally recommend!

T
Tim K.

This place really does live up to its name. The food is always hand-made with top-notch skill, and they serve exactly the kind of brand drinks that taste great with their menu.

B
Broconut